HOME
POWER LINES
STORE
GIFT
ABOUT US
Logo
LOG IN
SUBSCRIBE
Logo
SUBSCRIBE

The Free Press’ Follies

An A.I.-altered photo, a retracted video, and a quietly shelved interview have prompted fresh questions about the standards at Bari Weiss’ other publication.

Brett LoGiurato
Brett LoGiurato

Nov 15, 2026

The Free Press’ Follies

The Free Press’ Follies

An A.I.-altered photo, a retracted video, and a quietly shelved interview have prompted fresh questions about the standards at Bari Weiss’ other publication.

Brett LoGiurato
Brett LoGiurato

Nov 15, 2026

The Free Press’ Follies

On Sept. 29, author Anand Giridharadas walked into the Paramount building in New York City for the first time. He spent around an hour being interviewed on camera by Olivia Reingold, a staff writer for The Free Press and one of the publication’s most recognizable personalities, about his book, “Man in the Mirror,” which had been published that day.

He and Reingold had both covered the trial of Daniel Penny, the white former U.S. Marine who had placed a Black man, Jordan Neely, into a fatal chokehold on a New York subway and was later acquitted. Giridharadas’ book centers on the case, which divided America’s largest city and turned into a culture war flashpoint over public safety and race. He told Status he had sought out The Free Press interview, clearing much of his busy publication-day schedule because he believed it was the type of cross-aisle exchange that would resonate beyond his typical audience.

While he believed the conversation became exactly that, editors of The Free Press apparently felt differently. The outlet, co-founded and led by Bari Weiss, decided against running the interview—which, of course, it has the editorial prerogative to do. But staffers inside the anti-“woke” Substack publication offered Giridharadas varying explanations, he told Status. Throughout the process, as he heard little from Reingold and vague details from other staffers, he questioned whether The Free Press was “a blog that got a lot of money or an actual publication.”

The incident is one of several recent episodes that have prompted renewed scrutiny of The Free Press, the upstart, unabashedly pro-Israel opinion site overseen by Weiss. Though much has been written about Weiss’ stewardship of CBS News and its hallowed halls, comparatively little is known about the inner workings of her other media property, which now-Skydance boss David Ellison acquired in 2025 for a whopping $150 million while he elevated Weiss to the top role at CBS News.

In recent weeks, the publication has also been at the center of firestorms over incidents involving a reporter’s A.I.-altered election night photo and a video, since retracted and deleted, that misstated how Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed spoke in his own victory speech. Elsewhere, the publication corrected a story that incorrectly said another senator-elect, Iowa Democrat Josh Turek, had been a “Special Olympics” athlete—he had, in fact, been a Paralympian. Together, they have raised questions about the publication’s editorial processes and standards. Multiple editors at The Free Press—including deputy editor Oliver Wiseman, who appears to be one of the publication’s highest-ranking editors—did not respond to emails from Status requesting more information on the publication’s standards and editorial processes. A spokesperson for the outlet also did not provide comment.

One of those other incidents also involved Reingold. On election night, in an apparent attempt to make a point about the type of person associating with today’s Democratic Party, she wrote on X that she had spotted “Valentino heels, a Chanel bag, a Moncler jacket, Rolex watches, and a YSL bag” at El-Sayed’s election event. Within a couple of hours, she walked part of it back. The woman in the picture hadn't been at his party, but at one thrown by the Michigan Democratic Party, which Reingold proceeded to call "a data point for the entire state apparatus."

Then, the photo itself came under scrutiny from Vanity Fair's fashion desk, which suggested Reingold had used A.I. to generate or alter the image. Later, Reingold admitted she had used ChatGPT "to brighten and sharpen" the image. The A.I.-assisted photo remains on her feed, and she has insisted her initial observation “holds.”

But that is not how journalistic photo editing is supposed to work, at least according to the National Press Photographers Association. Its guidelines treat a news photograph as a kind of visual quotation, as Mickey Osterreicher, the NPPA's general counsel, told Status. He used an example of a reporter trimming an "um" from a quotation, which preserves the meaning. “A modest exposure adjustment, for example, can make a shoe strap easier to see,” he told me. “Asking a generative A.I. tool to brighten or sharpen that same photo may cause it to redraw the strap. The result can look clearer but be inaccurate. For a journalist, the question is whether the finished photograph faithfully and accurately depicts the scene as it was the moment the photo was taken.”

He added: “When the reporting rests on a detail in the photograph, that detail is evidence. Changing it can change what the story itself can truthfully say.”

The NPPA also holds that a materially altered image published as news should be corrected promptly and prominently where readers first saw it. Reingold didn’t respond to a request for comment for this story.

The day after Reingold’s photo stirred controversy, The Free Press’ social accounts posted a reaction video from reporter and host Maya Sulkin, who had watched El-Sayed’s victory speech and pointedly declared that the man who was set to become the first Muslim senator in the U.S. had delivered his speech “in Arabic.” The premise was incorrect. A community note later appended to the video on X noted that El-Sayed had used Arabic for 0.27% of his speech—using it, among a few common phrases, to say his own full name and crack a joke about JD Vance.

The Free Press appended a correction to the X post two days later, in the form of an additional post stating that the claim was "not accurate" and that the outlet "regrets the error." After two more days, however, the video was deleted, with a new statement saying it "contained a factual error and its tone fell short of what we believe advances healthy public discourse." The “rigorous editorial process that produces the work that appears on our website and in our newsletters must apply to everything we post on social media. We’ll be updating how we do things to achieve just that,” The Free Press added.

The publication did not provide further clarity. CBS News, of course, has its own set of guidelines, portions of which have been reviewed by Status. Those say the guiding principle in editing and presenting material is that “everything must be exactly what it purports to be,” and that the results of the editing process “must scrupulously reflect what actually happened.” The network’s guidelines also warn that technology has made it easier to “create a false impression of reality.”

Amid the other follies, Giridharadas went public last week with his own episode involving the publication. He told me he sees echoes in the processes that led to the split screen of both the errors and the apparent shelving of what he called an “engaging” piece of content.

After he taped the interview in late September, he heard nothing for days. Then, he said, he texted Reingold for an update on Oct. 4. Her reply contained bad news: The interview wouldn’t run. He said she told him that it had nothing to do with his views. Two days later, editor Josh Kaplan wrote to Giridharadas’ book publicist. According to Giridharadas, Kaplan said the shoot hadn't gone as planned and wasn't suitable to publish, and suggested that Reingold might write something instead. (Kaplan didn’t respond to a request for comment.)

Giridharadas said he heard nothing further about a written piece, and an email to Kaplan around a month later, on Nov. 5, went unanswered. The whole saga left him scratching his head.

“You had a literally non-human piece of content,” he said of the A.I. photo incident, and “a profoundly human piece of content”—his interview. “It saddens me greatly that of those two, they chose to publish the former and kill the latter.”

The latest episode of Power Lines is out.

In this week’s episode: CBS News’ “Face the Nation” is losing two of its top leaders. We break down what Bari Weiss might do next to remake the network’s venerable Sunday public affairs show—including whether she might look to replace host Margaret Brennan.

Also, buyouts are thinning out CBS, CNN, and ABC News. We unpack the anxiety and dread those newsrooms are feeling as potentially sweeping layoffs loom. Finally, Trumpworld is now turning its fire on right-wing media mogul Rupert Murdoch after Republicans’ midterm wipeout. We spotlight a warning shot from Breitbart over coverage at Fox News.

You can watch on YouTube—or listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. If you enjoy the program, subscribe so you never miss an episode!

Sean Duffy on NBC's "Meet the Press" with host Kristen Welker. (Screenshot via NBC News)

  • The meltdown at the FAA consumed a significant chunk of the weekend’s television news coverage, with much of the focus centering on the leadership of Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, the former “Real World” contestant and Fox News host.

    • Duffy’s press conference on the nationwide ground stop—which shut down air traffic in the U.S. for several hours Friday and snarled traffic the rest of the weekend—was stymied by tech issues. [WaPo]

    • Duffy completed the rare “Full Ginsburg,” appearing on all of the five major Sunday morning political talk shows on CBS, CNN, NBC, ABC, and Fox News. [RCP]

    • Meanwhile, Donald Trump was largely silent on the crisis. He broke his silence on Sunday, when he … wait for it … blamed the Joe Biden administration. [CNBC]

  • Joe Rogan weighed in with his most extensive comments yet on Republicans’ midterm wipeout, two years after he led the “manosphere” in backing Trump’s bid to return to the White House. “They didn’t just lose the podcast bros,” Rogan said of the GOP. “They lost most of the country.” [NYT]

  • James Murdoch, the estranged son of right-wing media mogul Rupert Murdoch, and his wife, Kathryn, recently explored acquiring Crooked Media, Adam Wren and Sarah Ellison reported. [POLITICO]

  • Well, that was fast: Jensen Huang is eyeing a comeback at Nvidia just days after he resigned as chief executive over his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy. He has the support of influential tech allies, including Elon Musk. [FT]

    • “Saturday Night Live” mocked the scandal, with Bowen Yang making a surprise return to play the ousted Nvidia cofounder. [Variety]

  • Billy Evans, the partner of Elizabeth Holmes, spoke with “CBS Sunday Morning” in his first interview since the release of A24’s “You Can See Everything.” [CBS]

    • Evans reacted to Amanda Seyfried’s portrayal of the disgraced Theranos founder, saying she was “eager” to “play a character.” [THR]

    • Speaking of Seyfried: She will host “SNL” next month. [Deadline]

  • James Gunn looked to dispel “rumors” about the future of “Man of Tomorrow.” He said “no one at Skydance” has seen the movie, amid speculation that the David Ellison-led company could make changes as Gunn and Peter Safran exit DC Studios. [THR]

  • HBO released the first clip from its upcoming “Harry Potter” series. [Deadline]

Johnny Depp in "Ebenezer." (Screenshot via YouTube/Paramount Pictures)

  • Johnny Depp returned to the top of the box office charts as “Ebenezer,” the Depp-starred take on “A Christmas Carol,” opened at No. 1 with $19 million.

  • Warner Bros.’ animated adaptation of “Cat in the Hat” remained in second place, garnering $11.4 million in its second weekend.

  • “Godzilla Minus Zero” slipped to third place in weekend No. 2, seeing a sharp 73% plunge from its winning debut.

  • The Indian epic “Ramayana: Rise of a Legend” placed fourth domestically, nabbing $5.5 million. Its global haul was much stronger, with the film approaching $150 million worldwide.

  • A24’s Elizabeth Holmes documentary, “You Can See Everything,” held strong in fifth place, also grabbing nearly $5.5 million. The Nathan Fielder- and Lance Oppenheim-directed film is approaching the $90 million mark domestically.

  • Amazon MGM’s “How to Rob a Bank,” the action comedy starring Nicholas Hoult, Zoë Kravitz, and Pete Davidson, flopped with just $5.2 million in its opening weekend.

[Data via Box Office Mojo]

Keep reading

VIEW MORE
caret-right
About Us
arrow-right
Archive
arrow-right
Go Premium
arrow-right
Quick Links

Home

Power Lines

Archive

Shop

Gift

About Us

Advertise With Us

Authors

Oliver Darcy

Jon Passantino

Natalie Korach

Brian Lowry

Status is the definitive nightly briefing that cuts through the noise to inform readers about what is really happening in the corridors of media power.

© 2026 Status News Inc..
beehiivPowered by beehiiv